Double-Blind Peer Review Policy
Perramus. Journal of Semiotic Studies on Graphic and Visual Media applies an external double-blind peer review system to ensure academic quality, impartiality, and scholarly integrity in all published contributions.
Type of Review
The journal operates under a double-blind peer review model, in which:
-
The identity of the author(s) is not disclosed to the reviewers;
-
The identity of the reviewers is not disclosed to the author(s).
This model is intended to guarantee an independent and objective evaluation of submitted manuscripts.
Editorial Process
-
Initial Editorial Screening
Upon submission, the editorial team conducts a preliminary assessment to verify:-
The relevance of the manuscript to the journal’s scope;
-
Compliance with submission guidelines;
-
Basic standards of originality and academic quality.
Manuscripts that do not meet these criteria may be rejected at this stage.
-
-
External Peer Review
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are sent to a minimum of two external reviewers, who are specialists in the relevant field and independent of the editorial team. -
Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers assess manuscripts based on:-
Originality and contribution to the field;
-
Methodological rigor and theoretical soundness;
-
Coherence and clarity of argumentation;
-
Adequacy and relevance of references;
-
Overall academic writing quality.
-
-
Editorial Decision
Based on the reviewers’ reports, the Editor-in-Chief may issue one of the following decisions:-
Accept;
-
Accept with minor revisions;
-
Revise and resubmit;
-
Reject.
In cases of substantially divergent reports, the manuscript may be sent to a third reviewer.
-
Confidentiality and Ethics
The peer review process is conducted under strict confidentiality. Reviewers are required to:
-
Treat manuscripts as confidential documents;
-
Declare any potential conflicts of interest;
-
Refrain from using unpublished material for personal advantage.
Transparency
Authors are informed of the status of their submission throughout the editorial process and receive a reasoned decision. Accepted manuscripts may require revisions prior to final publication.